Finders Keepers Vintage & Vinyl is an antique shop at 900 N Mill St, Plymouth, in the Old Village area. It focuses on vintage clothing, retro jewellery, vinyl records and music memorabilia, with more than 2,000 square feet to browse. The shop is run by Matthew and Kamie Mai, who opened it around 2010 after moving from their original location near Starkweather Street. Both have been involved in flea markets since childhood, and that background shows in the way the stock is sourced: the owners visit flea markets, antique centres and garage sales, including regular trips through Michigan and neighbouring states.
Every week we pick 🏆 the 5 best 🏆 things to do in Plymouth and send them to your inbox. Just one weekly email, no spam.
By submitting your email, you accept our Privacy Policy
The shop has a strong 1960s and 1970s feel. Its walls feature original or early-print rock posters, including a Jim Morrison design, while the record selection includes artists such as Pink Floyd, Metallica and Led Zeppelin. There are also unusual pieces such as a WLLZ 98.7 promotional lighting display. Stock changes regularly, with new items reportedly arriving at least twice a week, so the selection can vary from one visit to the next. The business sells in person only and does not operate an online shop. Reviews describe the records as clean and carefully graded, generally around EX, NM or M condition, while staff are often mentioned as friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. Prices vary widely: an original, scratch-free Led Zeppelin disc may reach £600 or more, and some jazz records have been priced at roughly £1,100–£1,500, so it is worth checking the condition and pressing details before buying.
As of Monday 28 September 2026, the listed opening hours are Tuesday to Friday from 12pm to 8pm, Saturday and Sunday from 12pm to 5pm, and closed on Mondays. Some public listings show different hours, so calling (734) 604-3463 before travelling would be sensible. There is free parking, and the shop is easy to combine with a walk around Old Village. For anyone interested in older clothing, original posters or well-kept records, Finders Keepers offers a hands-on browsing experience rather than an online catalogue.
Published Date
28 September 2026
